Fulfillment by Amazon vs. Third-Party Logistics: Which Shipping Distribution Option is Right for You?

shipping_distribution_options

Amazon fulfillment is one of the most popular fulfillment methods in the world today. Nearly all Amazon sellers use it — 96 percent according to JungleScout’s 2020 State of the Amazon Seller report, with only 29 percent using both. However, is the dominance of Amazon making retailers ignore third-party logistics solutions that might be better?

How Do Amazon Fulfillment and Third-Party Logistics Differ?

Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA) is precisely what it sounds like: all your goods are held by Amazon in their fulfillment centers. In contrast, third-party logistics allow sellers to hold and ship their own goods or have a third party warehouse them (these methods are referred to as fulfillment by merchant, or FBM).

Fulfillment methods can impact profit margins dramatically. The State of the Seller report likewise found that FBM was associated with more sales volume and a 5 percent increase in margin. The same report found that FBM sellers are up and running on Amazon more quickly. 

Who Does Amazon Fulfillment Work For?

While many organizations lean heavily on Amazon fulfillment, there’s a specific customer profile FBA works for. FBA is generally geared toward items that are small, cheap and light, with no prohibitions on comingling. Amazon also works best for retailers who need quick turnaround time and are short on warehouse space and manpower. 

So, while Amazon has been seen as the ideal shipping distribution choice for any retailer, the truth is that it’s actually best for smaller, lightweight items. 

Who Do Third-Party Logistics Work For?

Third-party logistics, on the other hand, are for companies with almost the opposite profile—those selling big, expensive, heavy items that can’t be comingled, who have with tons of warehouse space and an abundance of manpower.

It’s worth noting that companies using the FBM strategy can also qualify as Amazon Prime sellers.

Which Shipping Distribution Solution is Best for Your Organization?

FBM offers opportunities to scale through increased control that are not possible through Amazon fulfillment. Keep in mind that you have the potential to sell out of the same stock on your own website, just as you may on Amazon. Scaling with FBA can include increased fees, as well as increased shipping costs to Amazon warehouses and fulfillment centers. 

So while FBA has some advantages, size isn’t everything. Volume is also a crucial factor in determining which is the better opportunity. It bears repeating that moving to an FBM strategy will not necessarily mean an end to Prime seller status (which could result in lost revenue).

Ultimately, it’s a question of control: How much do you want? How much are you willing to sacrifice? 

James Pell is a freelance writer specializing in logistics, cybersecurity and fintech.

0 Comments

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Carteret, NJ

Address:
800 Federal Boulevard
Carteret, NJ 07008

Size: 300,000 sqft

Technology:
• RF Technology
• Narrow aisle high bay rack system
• Apparel and Accessories
• High value storage area, secured yard
• Transload and Pool consolidation
• Omnichannel distribution

Chino, CA #1 & #2

Address:
14050 Norton Ave,
Chino, CA 91710

Size: 400,000 sqft

Major Equipment:
• Automated high speed sortation
• Locus Robotics

Technology:
• Synapse
• Warehouse Management
• Transportation Management
• Routing & Compliance
• Document Management
• Custom Reporting
• Web Portal
• Electronic Data Interchange (EDI)

Specialty:
• Apparel
• Footwear
• Accessories
• Jewelry
• Bulk Materials

Processing:
• Wholesale, Retail, DTC
• Full Case Distribution
• Cross Dock
• Transload
• Pick & Pack
• Kitting
• VAS

JONATHAN ROSENTHAL - COB

Jonathan has spent a lifetime as an entrepreneur. He started his
first company, NetAir International, in 1983. It was innovative as
the first multi-city on-demand jet charter company and grew into
the largest operation of its kind in the U.S. His second venture was
in launching Saybrook Partners, a merchant bank in 1990 and
later Saybrook Corporate Opportunity Funds in 207. Jonathan
serves in numerous leadership roles, including as founder and
chairman of the LA Harbor Performance Enhancement Center,
WherehouseIT.com, and the Harvard Graduate School Leadership
Institute. He also serves on the Marine Transportation System
National Advisory Committee, Los Angeles Sustainable Freight
Advisory Board, and the University of Southern California Center
for Supply Chain Management board of directors. He earned a B.
A. in Philosophy from California State University, Northridge, B.A.
Sc. in International Law and Legal Studies from Uppsala
University and a J.D., law from Southwestern Law School.

Jonathan is passionate about both expanding and sharing his
knowledge and expertise. He has lectured in transformational
change at the University of Chicago, UCLA, John’s Hopkins, and
Harvard College.

JOE DESAYE - CEO TFMI

Joseph DeSaye has spent over 40 years in logistics. His journey began in 1980 when he co-founded FMI International with his father and brother, specializing in air and ocean forwarding services. Together, they expanded the company to include comprehensive services that grossed over $350 million in sales.

He has a proven track record of success, growth, and leadership within the logistics industry.

THOMAS MCCORMACK - CIO

Thomas has dedicated over 20 years of his career to working in IT for 3PL companies where he has grown to deeply understand the importance of keeping pace with a dynamic and ever-changing marketplace. Prior to joining Taylored in 2014, he led IT or a $2.8 billion window manufacturer and a $1.2 billion electronic media organization. He holds a degree in accelerated mathematics/calculus from LaGuardia Community College and an MBA with a focus on computer software engineering from Fordham University.

Thomas is passionate about coaching and mentoring teams and sharing his experience in cross-functional team leadership. He knows that one of the best ways to grow an organization in today’s society is through the implementation of effective technology that allows them to stay ahead.

MIKE YUSKO - CFO

Mike overseas finance, human resources, and legal at Taylored, as well as directing Taylored’s operating companies. After over 35 years in 3PL, vitamins and supplements, consumer products, engineering, and construction, he is a man of many talents. He has served as CFO at companies ranging in size from $50-$700 million and spent 15 years at PepsiCo as the senior finance leader of a $1.2 billion beverage unit.

Mike holds a B.S. in business administration and accounting from Clarion State College. He is passionate about providing solid leadership and applying “Fortune 50” know how to elevate smaller companies.

JIM DEVEAU - CEO

Jim Deveau is a retailer at heart, with over 20 years of experience leading in the retail industry with companies such as Lord & Taylor, AnnTaylor, Charming Shoppes, and Footstar. After assisting with Footstar’s restructure in 2004, Jim transitioned into the 3PL industry. Over the next ten years, he held various C-suite positions at FMI International, Summit International Logistics, and Toll Global Forwarding before becoming Taylored’s President and CEO and board director.

Jim is passionate about sharing his knowledge. Holding an undergraduate and graduate degree from Northeastern University, together with his extensive experience, he frequently speaks at industry trade shows and conferences and has been recognized as a leader within the industry. He also currently sits on the advisory board of warehouse exchange and was chosen by the US Chamber of Commerce to represent retail trade post 9/11.

Chino, CA #1 & #2

Address:
14050 Norton Ave,
Chino, CA 91710

Size: 400,000 sqft

Major Equipment:
• Automated high speed sortation
• Locus Robotics

Technology:
• Synapse
• Warehouse Management
• Transportation Management
• Routing & Compliance
• Document Management
• Custom Reporting
• Web Portal
• Electronic Data Interchange (EDI)

Specialty:
• Apparel
• Footwear
• Accessories
• Jewelry
• Bulk Materials

Processing:
• Wholesale, Retail, DTC
• Full Case Distribution
• Cross Dock
• Transload
• Pick & Pack
• Kitting
• VAS

Ontario, CA Suite A & B

Address:
1495 E. Locust Street
Ontario, CA 91761

Size: 440,000 sqft

Technology:
• Highjump
• Accellos
• Warehouse Management
• Transportation Management
• Routing & Compliance
• Document Management
• Custom Reporting
• Web Portal
• Electronic Data Interchange (EDI)

Specialty:
• Apparel
• Footwear
• Accessories
• Jewelry
• Sporting Goods
• Home Goods
• Bulk Materials

Processing:
• Wholesale, Retail, DTC
• Full Case Distribution
• Cross Dock
• Transload
• Pick & Pack
• Kitting
• VAS

Miami, FL

Address:
2100 NW 129th Ave, Suite 100
Miami, Fl 33182

Size: 319,000 sqft

Technology:
• RF Technology
• Narrow aisle high bay rack system
• Apparel and accessories
• Transload and pool consolidation
• Omnichannel distribution

Fontana, CA

Address:
8375 Sultana Ave
Fontana, CA 92335

Size: 225,000 sqft

Technology:
• Highjump
• Accellos
• Warehouse Management
• Transportation Management
• Routing & Compliance
• Document Management
• Custom Reporting
• Web Portal
• Electronic Data Interchange (EDI)

Specialty:
• Home Goods
• Bedding Accessories
• Electronics
• CPG Liquids

Processing:
• Wholesale, Retail, DTC
• Full Case Distribution
• Cross Dock
• Transload
• Pick & Pack
• Kitting
• VAS

Mira Loma, CA

Address:
3355 Dulles Avenue
Mira Loma, CA 91752

Size: 540,000 sqft

Major Equipment:
• Automated high speed sortation

Technology:
• FoxPro
• Warehouse Management
• Transportation Management
• Routing & Compliance
• Document Management
• Custom Reporting
• Web Portal
• Electronic Data Interchange (EDI)

Specialty:
• Home Goods
• Electronics
• Furniture

Processing:
• Wholesale, Retail, DTC
• Full Case Distribution
• Cross Dock
• Transload
• Pick & Pack
• Kitting
• VAS

Carson, CA #1 & #2

Address:
2000 East Carson St.
Carson, CA 90810
Size: 294,000 sqft

Technology:
• FoxPro
• Warehouse Management
• Transportation Management
• Routing & Compliance
• Document Management
• Custom Reporting
• Web Portal
• Electronic Data Interchange (EDI)

Specialty:
• Furniture

Processing:
• Retail, DTC
• Full Case Distribution
• Transload
• VAS

San Pedro, CA

Address:
400 Westmont Drive
San Pedro, CA 90731

Size: 513,000 sqft

Technology:
• FoxPro
• Warehouse Management
• Transportation Management
• Routing & Compliance
• Document Management
• Custom Reporting
• Web Portal
• Electronic Data Interchange (EDI)

Specialty:
• Apparel
• Footwear
• Electronics
• Furniture

Processing:
• Wholesale, Retail, DTC
• Full Case Distribution
• Cross Dock
• Transload
• Pick & Pack
• Kitting
• VAS

Port of LA, CA

Address:
2401 E Pacific Coast Hwy
Wilmington, CA 90744

Size: 600,000 sqft

Technology:
• FoxPro
• Warehouse Management
• Transportation Management
• Routing & Compliance
• Document Management
• Custom Reporting
• Web Portal
• Electronic Data Interchange (EDI)

Specialty:
• Electronics
• Furniture
• Bulk Materials
• Home Goods

Processing:
• Transload
• Kitting

Edison, NJ

Address:
231 Mill Road,
Edison, NJ 08837

Size: 260,000 sqft

Technology:
• RF Technology
• Wire guided high bay rack system
• Apparel and accessories
• High value storage area
• Store consolidation
• Omnichannel distribution

Louisville, KY

Address:
7501 Winstead Drive
Louisville, KY 40258

Size: 319,000 sqft

Technology:
• RF Technology
• Wire guided high bay rack system
• Apparel, footwear, and accessories
• Omnichannel distribution

Consult A Specialist